NRL Fantasy 2022 Part 3 - Max or Josh?

easytiger wrote:Anyone considering Braden Hamlen-Uele?

2019 averaged 36.9 in 36.5 mins (1.01PPM)
2020 averaged 36.7 in 42.8 mins (0.86PPM)
2021 averaged 28.5 in 39.5 mins (0.72PPM)

2021 under Josh Morris was 39.2 in 57.2 mins, vs under Josh Hannay 24.7 in 33.2 mins

mattnz wrote:
Sexton is less likely to be a season keeper. Burton will almost certainly be a keeper at center.

Milchcow wrote:
Just further on Burton

Dogs start out with easier games against Broncos and Cowboys, then have a tough run of Manly, Storm, Panthers Rabbitohs.

Few ways you can look at it
a) If he is underpriced by 10 points , then draw doesn't matter. Barring injury he is unlikely to get cheaper than his starting price.
b) Draw doesn't matter. He'll get attacking points against crap teams and kicking points against good ones
c) He will score well, but not well above starting price so you can start with a cheaper cash cow and bring Burton in several rounds in. This would let you get a look at him to see how his role/scoring is at the Dogs.
d) You just aren't interested in him in any way and look somewhere else (until/unless his scoring proves you wrong)

Milchcow wrote:

No wonder Josh Morris retired. Must have been hard coaching another team whilst also playing for the Roosters

easytiger wrote:

Touché
John, Josh, are they really any different bar a solitary letter

Fair points from the others.
I'm just desperate to throw my middles under the bus by having two under $400k  

mattnz wrote:

Need to compare him with Josh King and Bullemor at a lower price point.

easytiger wrote:

Already have them both  just seemingly trying to manufacture another

mattnz wrote:

I am looking at J King, Bullemor, Mann as my starting MIDs, with A Fifita and M King as my back up reserves.

rhinoceroo wrote:Wondering aloud whether if Papenhuyzen and Keary are both out for a couple of weeks it might be an idea to start with a 5/8th playing Joey Manu instead of Pap (he's WFB/CTR DPP, surprisingly), taking the points/maybe profit and trading after a few rounds?

Would feel wrong trading out a keeper centre in the first month, but if you start without Pap he still likely has to come in whenever he's back. If I knew it was one week would just start with him anyway, but who knows?

mattnz wrote:

I am looking at J King, Bullemor, Mann as my starting MIDs, with A Fifita and M King as my back up reserves.

rhinoceroo wrote:Wondering aloud whether if Papenhuyzen and Keary are both out for a couple of weeks it might be an idea to start with a 5/8th playing Joey Manu instead of Pap (he's WFB/CTR DPP, surprisingly), taking the points/maybe profit and trading after a few rounds?

Would feel wrong trading out a keeper centre in the first month, but if you start without Pap he still likely has to come in whenever he's back. If I knew it was one week would just start with him anyway, but who knows?

mattnz wrote:

I am looking at J King, Bullemor, Mann as my starting MIDs, with A Fifita and M King as my back up reserves.

Milchcow wrote:

What do you think of his scoring chances at 6? Only 2 games there but base isn't good

Also would you hold him as a keeper when he moved back to the centres, or trade him to Pappy/Burton.Burd/whoever

Hannah2 wrote:

I read a comment from Bellamy that he's playing with the idea of Munster filling in FB, so that indicates to me that Pap is in doubt for a few weeks.

easytiger wrote:In terms of Sexton, the stability of that spine worries me:

1. Campbell (6 NRL games)
6. Brimson (15 NRL games at 5/8, 58 starts)
7. Sexton (4 NRL games)
9. Clark (11 NRL games starting Hooker, 28 overall)
may split time with Boyd (21 games, 8 in the halves, the rest INT)

I'm struggling to think of a time with an NRL team started with a more inexperienced spine, and how that went. That's a lot of pressure on a lot of inexperience.

standard-issue wrote:

I personally don't think @Snatchpato is the kinda guy to have an alt...