HomeKrump wrote:Wrong decision. He didn't intentionally tap it forward he intentionally kept it in play.
By? Tapping it over Watson. Correct call.
NRL Round One
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8355
Reputation : 5663
Join date : 2015-09-28
By? Tapping it over Watson. Correct call.
Krump- Posts : 8454
Reputation : 4770
Join date : 2015-07-31
Location : Your mums room
isnt the rule only if its intentionally forward?Honeysett wrote:
By? Tapping it over Watson. Correct call.
BroncHose- Posts : 1325
Reputation : 324
Join date : 2016-03-16
I was literally just looking at Glasby's scores thinking - phew, dodged a bullet there
Krump- Posts : 8454
Reputation : 4770
Join date : 2015-07-31
Location : Your mums room
No fucking way that's a penalty try
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8355
Reputation : 5663
Join date : 2015-09-28
That's a disgusting decision
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8355
Reputation : 5663
Join date : 2015-09-28
Krump wrote:isnt the rule only if its intentionally forward?
That's what I mean though, he intentionally taps it forward and over him
Krump- Posts : 8454
Reputation : 4770
Join date : 2015-07-31
Location : Your mums room
Karma right there
Honeysett- Moderator
- Posts : 8355
Reputation : 5663
Join date : 2015-09-28
Shouldn't have been on the field but shouldn't have been a penalty try. Balance is restored.
Krump- Posts : 8454
Reputation : 4770
Join date : 2015-07-31
Location : Your mums room
If the Sharks don't get the penalty try Lee would have got binned, they likely score with him off and maybe win the game. Scoring a try could well have cost them the game 
No Worries- Moderator
- NRL FF Survivor Champion : I'm like the waterboy.
Posts : 10369
Reputation : 7081
Join date : 2015-07-31
2/121 after 2 games if anyone's counting
Goodnight Kiwi- Posts : 1089
Reputation : 988
Join date : 2018-01-09
Location : Christchurch
Understand the decision to open up a specific thread for each round Admin, but you got my refreshing two pages now (on top of listening via Radio and refreshing MTBs stats page).... And seeing @NoWorries package twice more than necessary
No Worries- Moderator
- NRL FF Survivor Champion : I'm like the waterboy.
Posts : 10369
Reputation : 7081
Join date : 2015-07-31
Aubbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbsssssssssssssssssssssssss
No Worries- Moderator
- NRL FF Survivor Champion : I'm like the waterboy.
Posts : 10369
Reputation : 7081
Join date : 2015-07-31
@Goodnight Kiwi This one's for you 
Goodnight Kiwi- Posts : 1089
Reputation : 988
Join date : 2018-01-09
Location : Christchurch
standard-issue- Moderator
- Posts : 19196
Reputation : 9395
Join date : 2015-08-03
Age : 28
Goodnight Kiwi wrote:Understand the decision to open up a specific thread for each round Admin, but you got my refreshing two pages now (on top of listening via Radio and refreshing MTBs stats page).... And seeing @NoWorries package twice more than necessary
leaguegod- Posts : 1204
Reputation : 141
Join date : 2015-11-24
my thoughts re the penalty try:
1. Belters like blocker saying he has to be 100% certain help breed ref faulters, commentators need to know the fucking rules. the rule doesn't say 100%, it says that in refs opinion a try would have been scored. i personally think we should see more penalty tries then we have in the past
2. Last night however was probably not a great example, that big bounce to the right made it seem unlikely he would have scored imo
3. in saying that, at the time i said to myself, i wonder if cronulla would rather a man in the bin. i know a guranteed try is still the better odds play but if they score that set anyways and then still have 9 minutes against 12 men, that could have been huge and in hindsight they probably would have been better off lol.
knights defense not being the worst in the comp may make me re-think where i had them, its only round 1 but that was a pretty clear improvement on last year defensively
Cameron murrey > victor radley imo, Radley is a nutter and pulls of some belters but murrey is brilliant all round, so much stronger then he looks
1. Belters like blocker saying he has to be 100% certain help breed ref faulters, commentators need to know the fucking rules. the rule doesn't say 100%, it says that in refs opinion a try would have been scored. i personally think we should see more penalty tries then we have in the past
2. Last night however was probably not a great example, that big bounce to the right made it seem unlikely he would have scored imo
3. in saying that, at the time i said to myself, i wonder if cronulla would rather a man in the bin. i know a guranteed try is still the better odds play but if they score that set anyways and then still have 9 minutes against 12 men, that could have been huge and in hindsight they probably would have been better off lol.
knights defense not being the worst in the comp may make me re-think where i had them, its only round 1 but that was a pretty clear improvement on last year defensively
Cameron murrey > victor radley imo, Radley is a nutter and pulls of some belters but murrey is brilliant all round, so much stronger then he looks
Pieman- Posts : 3553
Reputation : 386
Join date : 2015-10-26
It clearly should have been a binning and not a PT.. the ball rolls to the right and away from him nearly instantly. He may have scored and was denied the opportunity but Jeez, Watson wasn't far off and the ball was rolling away.
The tap over the head was the correct call. Cant intentionally tap it forward like that.
Was a fairly shit game for the most part I thought. Cronulla bombed 3/4 tries but with bad timing out to their right edge. Doooougs not passing it cost them a certain try. They will click and will be very very hard to beat IMO. Was good seeing gallen drop it at the end, fuck him.
As I suspected, the games last night were refereed totally differently to the first game. There were that many penalties in the ruck for holding down and niggling, whereas on Thursday players were allowed to do whatever they wanted. The difference was as clear as day to me.
I still dont like Ponga at 6... he looked prob the least dangerous he ever has last night, with Watson being nothing more than an OK player. I would love for us to go after a good 6 so that we can put ponga back to fullback. I wouldn't hate us trying Mann at 6 instead of hooker. Push Watson to the bench hooker and utility back role that he is best suited to.
I am loving the Knights forward pack. In the past we have had bench quality players starting and playing big minutes. Now we have quality on the bench and starting. I like sione, but he is just too small to be a full-time first grade starting back-rower IMO.
Also they stopped play so Woods could get his head taped... fuck me dead refs, use ur new rules. Should have been moved to the side and play continue.
The tap over the head was the correct call. Cant intentionally tap it forward like that.
Was a fairly shit game for the most part I thought. Cronulla bombed 3/4 tries but with bad timing out to their right edge. Doooougs not passing it cost them a certain try. They will click and will be very very hard to beat IMO. Was good seeing gallen drop it at the end, fuck him.
As I suspected, the games last night were refereed totally differently to the first game. There were that many penalties in the ruck for holding down and niggling, whereas on Thursday players were allowed to do whatever they wanted. The difference was as clear as day to me.
I still dont like Ponga at 6... he looked prob the least dangerous he ever has last night, with Watson being nothing more than an OK player. I would love for us to go after a good 6 so that we can put ponga back to fullback. I wouldn't hate us trying Mann at 6 instead of hooker. Push Watson to the bench hooker and utility back role that he is best suited to.
I am loving the Knights forward pack. In the past we have had bench quality players starting and playing big minutes. Now we have quality on the bench and starting. I like sione, but he is just too small to be a full-time first grade starting back-rower IMO.
Also they stopped play so Woods could get his head taped... fuck me dead refs, use ur new rules. Should have been moved to the side and play continue.
Last edited by Pieman on Sun Mar 17, 2019 4:08 pm; edited 1 time in total
Krump- Posts : 8454
Reputation : 4770
Join date : 2015-07-31
Location : Your mums room
Everyone knew the dogs would be bad but fuck me that was ugly
leaguegod- Posts : 1204
Reputation : 141
Join date : 2015-11-24
It was fun enjoying the nrl season for 5 minutes
Who else is ready for origin talk ??
Who else is ready for origin talk ??
No Worries- Moderator
- NRL FF Survivor Champion : I'm like the waterboy.
Posts : 10369
Reputation : 7081
Join date : 2015-07-31
leaguegod wrote:It was fun enjoying the nrl season for 5 minutes
Who else is ready for origin talk ??
Do you want me to start an eliminator comp so you have something in your life ?
Similar topics
