Trade Targets - Round 4

So basically 20 options (max poll size) really limited my options this week in posting ideas. So I combined some of the names into a single line. If they get a lot of votes it'll let me know people like the idea and I can run a second poll to pick the right player. Note: I don't think Moses is a premium half but to get Salmon in the list of 20 that's the best I could do.

225k in the bank



Vote:
1. For the Number of Trades
2. Who you'd trade in
3. Who you'd trade out
4. You can change your mind at any time but the poll will lock in 1 day (just before Midnight Wednesday AEDT)

--------Trades----------
0 trades
1 trade
2 trade
-----------In-----------
Tedesco
Other WFB (Ponga, TTurbo, RTS)
Bateman
Cartwright
CHT
Salmon
Xerri
Premium HLF (DCE, Arey, Cleary, SJ, Munster, Moses)
Twal
----------Out-----------
Mahoney
Edwards
Lane
Macca
Burns
Keighran
Brown
Arrow

Some of the most interesting ideas proposed so far:

Prior to TLT @Rippin and Tearin

Macca to Teddy
Lane/Mahoney to Bateman
138k/78k left (we are 7k short of Lane and Mahoney to Tedesco and Bateman)

Post TLT @Rippin and Tearin

Lane to Teddy
Mahoney to Ponga
28k left

@Milchy

Keighran to Cartwright
Edwards to Tedesco
0k remaining

Hey, Am I wrong in saying we have to get a 1/2 with both Brown and Keighran out?

THEGAME wrote:Hey, Am I wrong in saying we have to get a 1/2 with both Brown and Keighran out?

Yeah man, need a half, thats the first priority. Hence the poll on which half to take.

Scrap my first trade option obviously cause that was suggested prior to Brown and Keighran out.

I actually think the biggest call this week is whether or not we have faith in Edwards.

I kinda like Milch's trade option although Im a little worried about playing WFB roulette on the two Fijians.. That said they have not well outperformed Edwards to date, but that is all because Edwards has been shit. Will he turn it around?

Ponga is value for sure, perhaps even better than Teddy, but you have to take into account price change timing. If you believe Ponga is gonna average 50+ then that means you want both in your team. Teddy this week, Ponga the next (or the one after) is by far the better way to go. So while I can see an argument for Ponga being better value (based on last years averages), Teddy is the smarter buy this week.

Also, can someone tell me more about Ponga's role? Is he now back at FB full time? Cause if not, then the value is no longer there....

Milchy wrote:
My plan would involve getting Ponga in over the next couple weeks, then we could switch him asround through the WFB or HLF depending on where we thought we were strong each week.
But no doubt there will be a bunch of injuries between now and next week to make it hard to plan on bringing him in.

Yeah man, I think that is the most sensible plan, both for this week and as far as we can reasonably look in the future.... I'll be voting for that.

Vote isn't quite closed but barring a massive 5 minute swing we are trading

Edwards -> Tedesco
Keighran -> Cartwright