NRL Fantasy Fanatics



Join the forum, it's quick and easy

NRL Fantasy Fanatics

NRL Fantasy Fanatics - A place for discussion of NRL Fantasy / Virtual Sports / Super Coach and other Fantasy Sports

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    robelgordo
    robelgordo
    Fanatic

    Posts : 12331
    Reputation : 8813
    Join date : 2019-07-07
    Location : Sydney

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by robelgordo Mon Jun 03, 2024 12:43 pm

    mattnz wrote:

    Radley isnt playing this week.

    Yeah my bad

    Still think he should get EDG
    Chewie
    Chewie
    Fanatic

    Posts : 17277
    Reputation : 12027
    Join date : 2016-02-02
    Location : Kashyyyk

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Chewie Mon Jun 03, 2024 12:44 pm

    RECAP NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 46 - Shoes off Edition

    - Knights vs Doggies live forum commentary continued (page 1)
    - Footystats comments taking off (page 1,2)
    - Lipoi debut video (page 7)
    - Dylan Edwards in doubt for origin with quad injury (page 8-10)
    - Addo-Car ruled out for 8-10 weeks (page 9)
    - Panthers vs Dragons live forum commentary (page 11-16)
    - Dolphins vs Raiders live forum commentary (page 17-22)
    - Live chat available now during games on footystats (page 17)
    - Teddy called up for origin duties (page 26-30)
    - Dylan Edwards potentially out for 4-6 weeks rumour (page 28)
    - Sharpe to debut for the Knights? - Baz (page 31,32)
    - Chester out of final teamlist (page 33)
    - Roosters vs Cowboys live forum commentary (page 34-40)
    - Matto's been suffering from concussion symptoms (page 36,46)
    - Simonsson ACL tear, needs surgery (page 36, 47)
    - End of Round how big is yours? (page 41-43)
    - Host calf injury, 6 weeks? rumour (page 47)
    - Simpkin signs with the Sea Eagles (page 47,48)
    - Bodyslam Gif Party (page 51,52)
    robelgordo
    robelgordo
    Fanatic

    Posts : 12331
    Reputation : 8813
    Join date : 2019-07-07
    Location : Sydney

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by robelgordo Mon Jun 03, 2024 12:44 pm

    rhinoceroo wrote:I'd argue with the Talakai one there... hasn't played a minute of EDG off the bench. Not that it's fantasy-relevant but he could legit get a CTR/MID DPP.

    I thought he’s started EDG a few times but agree could be MID. I’d argue he’s clearly a forward now and needs one of those positions DPP. But will likely get nothing.

    There’s probably a lot more bench forwards named as EDG in Fantasy that really play MID every week I’ve missed too
    Robertneville
    Robertneville

    Posts : 386
    Reputation : 510
    Join date : 2023-03-31

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Robertneville Mon Jun 03, 2024 1:23 pm

    Jele wrote:From @BCT05 in the last thread:

    "Well, PSA I can confirm the AE's are not advanced enough to sub a DPP emg into the most optimal position considering other AE's below.

    So for my team I had a red dot in half and two red dots in wfb, Weekes highest spot on bench then Tracey then Cole. It took Weekes into Half and Tracey into wfb and left Cole out. Annoying.

    Ended up with 639 instead of 678 and basically held rank."


    That sucks, sorry to hear. Mine worked out - I had red dots at HLF (Galvin), CTR (Koula) and WFB (Teddy) filled by Iro, Atkinson, and Strange (listed in that order on my bench).

    I wonder if it was because technically Teddy was recorded as not playing first, before Galvin on a bye, so Atkinson covered WFB first.

    After Tedesco was ruled out and my lowest scoring player had the VC I lost interest in the round and forgot all about having a similar DPP setup.

    I had HOK and HLF spots open, with my bench ordered Hands(HOK/HLF), Brailey(HOK), Cole(HLF).

    So logically Hands being DPP should've gone HLF with the 2nd player available being a HOK, but Hands instead subbed in at HOK, Brailey was skipped and Cole came in at HLF.

    I scored 654 instead of 662, only 8 points difference but more confirmation the system is still dumb AF.
    The Pascoe Fiasco
    The Pascoe Fiasco

    Posts : 2323
    Reputation : 1004
    Join date : 2019-02-03

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by The Pascoe Fiasco Mon Jun 03, 2024 1:38 pm

    I don’t understand why Talagi would get DPP. He was injury cover at 5/8 then injury cover at FB then dropped. Surely he gets named at centre (which he already is designated) and Russell goes out to the wing. How would he qualify for a DPP?
    Jele
    Jele

    NFL Fantasy L1 Champion : 2019
    NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2020
    Posts : 2382
    Reputation : 1275
    Join date : 2015-12-25

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Jele Mon Jun 03, 2024 1:51 pm

    Robertneville wrote:

    After Tedesco was ruled out and my lowest scoring player had the VC I lost interest in the round and forgot all about having a similar DPP setup.

    I had HOK and HLF spots open, with my bench ordered Hands(HOK/HLF), Brailey(HOK), Cole(HLF).

    So logically Hands being DPP should've gone HLF with the 2nd player available being a HOK, but Hands instead subbed in at HOK, Brailey was skipped and Cole came in at HLF.

    I scored 654 instead of 662, only 8 points difference but more confirmation the system is still dumb AF.

    Who were your non-playing HOK and HLF in your lineup?
    standard-issue
    standard-issue
    Moderator

    Posts : 19339
    Reputation : 9608
    Join date : 2015-08-03
    Age : 28

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by standard-issue Mon Jun 03, 2024 1:53 pm

    Jele wrote:From @BCT05 in the last thread:

    "Well, PSA I can confirm the AE's are not advanced enough to sub a DPP emg into the most optimal position considering other AE's below.

    So for my team I had a red dot in half and two red dots in wfb, Weekes highest spot on bench then Tracey then Cole. It took Weekes into Half and Tracey into wfb and left Cole out. Annoying.

    Ended up with 639 instead of 678 and basically held rank."


    That sucks, sorry to hear. Mine worked out - I had red dots at HLF (Galvin), CTR (Koula) and WFB (Teddy) filled by Iro, Atkinson, and Strange (listed in that order on my bench).

    I wonder if it was because technically Teddy was recorded as not playing first, before Galvin on a bye, so Atkinson covered WFB first.

    Either way, it seems like just unfortunate bad luck and a one off.
    Robertneville
    Robertneville

    Posts : 386
    Reputation : 510
    Join date : 2023-03-31

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Robertneville Mon Jun 03, 2024 2:01 pm

    Jele wrote:

    Who were your non-playing HOK and HLF in your lineup?

    Cook and Galvin
    Jele
    Jele

    NFL Fantasy L1 Champion : 2019
    NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2020
    Posts : 2382
    Reputation : 1275
    Join date : 2015-12-25

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Jele Mon Jun 03, 2024 2:05 pm

    Robertneville wrote:

    Cook and Galvin

    As you say dumb AF.
    Daedalus
    Daedalus

    Posts : 628
    Reputation : 712
    Join date : 2019-03-05
    Age : 36

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Daedalus Mon Jun 03, 2024 6:05 pm

    Robertneville wrote:

    After Tedesco was ruled out and my lowest scoring player had the VC I lost interest in the round and forgot all about having a similar DPP setup.

    I had HOK and HLF spots open, with my bench ordered Hands(HOK/HLF), Brailey(HOK), Cole(HLF).

    So logically Hands being DPP should've gone HLF with the 2nd player available being a HOK, but Hands instead subbed in at HOK, Brailey was skipped and Cole came in at HLF.

    I scored 654 instead of 662, only 8 points difference but more confirmation the system is still dumb AF.

    I’ve always wondered if this kind of thing is driven by the way the DPP is listed. Because Weekes is a HLF/WFB he comes in at Half first if there’s a spot there for him. Same with Hands as HOK is listed first in his DPP.

    There’s a whole range of players who are WFB/CTR where others are CTR/WFB for example, I suspect that factors into some logic or they’d just list them all in the same order to start the season

    But also, it is dumb AF
    manlybeaver
    manlybeaver

    Posts : 1596
    Reputation : 424
    Join date : 2015-11-06

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by manlybeaver Mon Jun 03, 2024 6:27 pm

    After trades and only having 3 left pretty happy with my team.

    Api
    Hopgood plath king
    Fifita Angus
    Hynes galvin
    Aitken tago
    Garrick kiraz weekes

    Brailey curran twal kpp

    Wighton hands iro armstrong
    the_great_wobbler
    the_great_wobbler

    Posts : 1056
    Reputation : 785
    Join date : 2021-05-14

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by the_great_wobbler Mon Jun 03, 2024 6:51 pm

    Daedalus wrote:

    I’ve always wondered if this kind of thing is driven by the way the DPP is listed. Because Weekes is a HLF/WFB he comes in at Half first if there’s a spot there for him. Same with Hands as HOK is listed first in his DPP.

    There’s a whole range of players who are WFB/CTR where others are CTR/WFB for example, I suspect that factors into some logic or they’d just list them all in the same order to start the season

    But also, it is dumb AF

    Only a couple of data points but to me it looks like the relevant thing is that they get filled in what looks like reading order down the page. I.e. in BCTs case half gets filled first and takes the highest positioned available player which happens to be Weekes. I don't think the order of DPP matters but it is a bit of a guess.

    To be honest, if it is done like that, the implementation makes sense to me. It should be explained better in the rules section though which doesn't describe the order the AEs are applied.
    BCT05
    BCT05

    Posts : 5072
    Reputation : 2192
    Join date : 2020-03-18

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by BCT05 Mon Jun 03, 2024 8:27 pm

    the_great_wobbler wrote:

    Only a couple of data points but to me it looks like the relevant thing is that they get filled in what looks like reading order down the page. I.e. in BCTs case half gets filled first and takes the highest positioned available player which happens to be Weekes. I don't think the order of DPP matters but it is a bit of a guess.

    To be honest, if it is done like that, the implementation makes sense to me. It should be explained better in the rules section though which doesn't describe the order the AEs are applied.

    Yep can only guess this must be the case, which yeah they should just add a note that this is how it works. At the moment it just makes mention that a DPP will sub in to a spot unless "required for another DNP player" which is very ambiguous. Surprised I've never come across that situation before, lessons learned.
    multiple.scoregasms
    multiple.scoregasms
    Fanatic

    Posts : 10167
    Reputation : 7681
    Join date : 2015-10-29
    Age : 31

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by multiple.scoregasms Mon Jun 03, 2024 8:57 pm

    manlybeaver wrote:After trades and only having 3 left pretty happy with my team.

    Api
    Hopgood plath king
    Fifita Angus
    Hynes galvin
    Aitken tago
    Garrick kiraz weekes

    Brailey curran twal kpp

    Wighton hands iro armstrong

    Few question marks about role/job security, but everyone except Armstrong/Weekes looks like a hold in the medium term

    Should actually do pretty well despite the lack of trades
    robelgordo
    robelgordo
    Fanatic

    Posts : 12331
    Reputation : 8813
    Join date : 2019-07-07
    Location : Sydney

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by robelgordo Mon Jun 03, 2024 8:58 pm

    The Pascoe Fiasco wrote:I don’t understand why Talagi would get DPP. He was injury cover at 5/8 then injury cover at FB then dropped. Surely he gets named at centre (which he already is designated) and Russell goes out to the wing. How would he qualify for a DPP?

    Ok then, so why does Manu have DPP?

    In the last few seasons, he’s been injury cover at 5/8 then injury cover at FB, but always gets named at CTR otherwise
    Liverpool_Bulldog
    Liverpool_Bulldog
    Fanatic

    Posts : 18936
    Reputation : 6533
    Join date : 2016-02-14
    Location : New Zealand

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Liverpool_Bulldog Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:03 pm

    Why doesn’t Cook get CTR? Plays there every now and again
    BBowler
    BBowler

    Posts : 1070
    Reputation : 596
    Join date : 2018-04-10

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by BBowler Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:03 pm

    Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:
    Why would Talagi get it?

    He’s had quite a few FB games since the last update?
    robelgordo
    robelgordo
    Fanatic

    Posts : 12331
    Reputation : 8813
    Join date : 2019-07-07
    Location : Sydney

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by robelgordo Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:06 pm

    Liverpool_Bulldog wrote:Why doesn’t Cook get CTR? Plays there every now and again

    Not sure if serious…
    Khany
    Khany

    Posts : 6147
    Reputation : 2183
    Join date : 2019-02-23

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by Khany Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:06 pm

    I'll bet my left nut Talagi gets dpp
    robelgordo
    robelgordo
    Fanatic

    Posts : 12331
    Reputation : 8813
    Join date : 2019-07-07
    Location : Sydney

    NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time - Page 2 Empty Re: NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 47 - Origin time

    Post by robelgordo Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:08 pm

    Whether he does or doesn’t, someone explain to me Manu being different. Or Garrick for that matter. Provably quite a few others too. Its all guesswork but I’m just working off the precedent


    Last edited by robelgordo on Mon Jun 03, 2024 9:09 pm; edited 1 time in total

      Current date/time is Tue Jun 25, 2024 8:37 am