NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 46 - You say which fantasy group is at the top? I Can't Believe It's Not Butters

Or should I just hold Soni and save the trade even if he loses some more money?

Rabbits21 wrote:Or should I just hold Soni and save the trade even if he loses some more money?

I’d hold mate, neither Tatola or Luki are a screaming buy

Can flick Luke to VTW next week if named or Oloapu once he starts

Rabbits21 wrote:Looking at Soni to Tatola or Luki which one would you get…

TU Tatola
TD Luki

At the start of the week I would've said Luki but the more I look at it:

Tatola - averages 42 when playing 40-50mins

Luki - averages 38 when playing 50-70mins (which seems to be what he will continue getting)


And Tatola is $23k cheaper.

Unless it seems that Tatola is now not going to get 40mins minimum? Interested in your thoughts on that Rabbits.

Don't mind Tass as a ctr option.

Is there any info out there on Aitken's hammy? Currently convincing myself on VTW instead of risking it with ponga...

What could go wrong?

Need to decide today as i'm trading out katoa who I've given too many lives to as it is

my tv broke wrote:

Does tatola or luki improve your 17? Whose place are they taking?

Seems like a forced trade unless you are actually playing Soni

Not much has changed for Luki but i dont think hes an urgent buy. He probably continues to have mins managed for a few weeks.

Tatola doesnt interest me but thats because i dont like buying straight up and down mid tier props. No fun there

Thanks mate I think I’ll just go Murray to Hopgood and Ford to Horse. Tatola avg 48.5mins over origin period last year he should increase in mins over origin.

But yeah you’re probs right they’d be my 18th man. I’m just thinking about round 13 but maybe it’s best to wait til closer. Bringing in Hopgood and Horse gives me 9 round 13 players Ideally I think I need 12.

I can still field this, this week….

Boyd
Horse Haas De Belin
Preston Hosking
Cleary SJ
Bird Manu
Teddy Bula Miller

Hopgood Loiero Cheese AJ
Lemu I. Kat Soni Couchman


Look strong enough? Plan is to get Robson for Loiero or Preston next week and I still have 282k spare

Revraiser wrote:It's a situation most will have looked away from now fantasy wise, but does anyone see Hands becoming the dominant guy at the Eels at Hooker ? Seems saving 'face' getting in the way. Or maybe they end up bringing in a new guy altogether.

Hands will no doubt become the first choice hooker at some point. He is highly rated and recently signed a new deal with the Eels. Might happen sooner rather than later if the Eels/Hodgson don't improve.

Fantasy wise, I haven't seen any indication Hands will be a good scorer, but may grow into it.

BCT05 wrote:

At the start of the week I would've said Luki but the more I look at it:

Tatola - averages 42 when playing 40-50mins

Luki - averages 38 when playing 50-70mins (which seems to be what he will continue getting)


And Tatola is $23k cheaper.

Unless it seems that Tatola is now not going to get 40mins minimum? Interested in your thoughts on that Rabbits.

At the moment the 4 forwards on the bench isn’t good for Tatola. I do think we will carry a Mamozelos or Ta’affe in a couple of games over origin, Havili is back in a few weeks too and Shaq isn’t far off either. Tatola will probs stay at around low 40’s mins next two weeks the fact he only played 33mins last week was odd but I do think it increases to high 40’s over origin. Round 13 he will probs play 50-55mins.

Ponga Yeo the Mann wrote:Is there any info out there on Aitken's hammy? Currently convincing myself on VTW instead of risking it with ponga...

What could go wrong?

Need to decide today as i'm trading out katoa who I've given too many lives to as it is

No info on Dolphins website yet

Need an Oloapu prayer circle for him to start to make my trades simple

Currently thinking Preston + Ford to Brown + Tatola but really not the greatest fan of Tatola/Luki

Probably just be better off taking Host and Bula score this week and holding trades

Revraiser wrote:It's a situation most will have looked away from now fantasy wise, but does anyone see Hands becoming the dominant guy at the Eels at Hooker ? Seems saving 'face' getting in the way. Or maybe they end up bringing in a new guy altogether.

I'm thinking of flicking him to Te Whare before he bleeds more cash. The increase to 50 mins was promising, but then 36 and a lowly 25 last week doesn't look like they're building towards 80 or 50 minimum. Probably lose another 15-20k this week and I don't think 15 points in Rd 13 is worth keeping him with some decent guns available in HK/HLF. Seems like Hodgo would need a 4+ week break for Hands to start making cash. Just wondering if it's worth eating the loss this week for more certainty on Te Whare.

Camo123 wrote:Need an Oloapu prayer circle for him to start to make my trades simple

Currently thinking Preston + Ford to Brown + Tatola but really not the greatest fan of Tatola/Luki

Probably just be better off taking Host and Bula score this week and holding trades

Host and Bula can't be worse than my Bula, Sele, Billy Smith and Oloapu quartet.
Praying there's no late injuries or drops.

Nothing wrong with playing those two this week. Round 13 Ford probably a better shout than Luki

Slowly coming round to holding Ford this week and just hoping Sele manages to tack on a LB or a few TBs to his score this week.

Ford to Billy Smith
Luke to Garrick

Shores up my round 13 numbers(wouldn’t sell Ford if I didn’t need a centre) and removes a dead spot in Luke. Thoughts on these trades?

danseels1985 wrote:Ford to Billy Smith
Luke to Garrick

Shores up my round 13 numbers(wouldn’t sell Ford if I didn’t need a centre) and removes a dead spot in Luke. Thoughts on these trades?

Do you also own Miller? If so you might have a problem in round 14

TU: Ponga (i'm expecting an uptick, or an eventual move back to FB if the uptick doesn't come)
TD: VTW + cash

Comment: neither ya loose unit

Weiland wrote:

Hands will no doubt become the first choice hooker at some point. He is highly rated and recently signed a new deal with the Eels. Might happen sooner rather than later if the Eels/Hodgson don't improve.

Fantasy wise, I haven't seen any indication Hands will be a good scorer, but may grow into it.

WT Winfield wrote:

I'm thinking of flicking him to Te Whare before he bleeds more cash. The increase to 50 mins was promising, but then 36 and a lowly 25 last week doesn't look like they're building towards 80 or 50 minimum. Probably lose another 15-20k this week and I don't think 15 points in Rd 13 is worth keeping him with some decent guns available in HK/HLF. Seems like Hodgo would need a 4+ week break for Hands to start making cash. Just wondering if it's worth eating the loss this week for more certainty on Te Whare.

Thanks u legends.

I think that's it,in some part not actually looking gud anyway as a scorer. And I have the same thing in my mind for him and Te Whare, want to do it now but it looks very unstable. Or maybe Wayne simply meant yeh he has alot to learn, and let's see if he sinks or swims at the same time.

Ponga Yeo the Mann wrote:TU: Ponga (i'm expecting an uptick, or an eventual move back to FB if the uptick doesn't come)
TD: VTW + cash

Comment: neither ya loose unit

Hold unless you really really have to trade you loose unit!

Life Sava it's the Flava!

Flava:

Origin talk = panic!

Still flip flopping between these

TU: Matterson
TD: Hopgood

Or should I just get DBags