NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 4 - It's go time !

Finger Puppet Mafia wrote:

Big Rick??

PatRICK Carrigan!

More of a Rick with that wonder tache he was sporting

rhinoceroo wrote:

Apart from the fact that Egan Butcher played almost exclusively as a bench mid last year, there's no reason for him to get dual :/

He's been categorised as an edge, he'll probably be named as an edge in Round 1 (if Angus is missing), he won't be a starting prop, so they're not going to change it. They've accidented on his correct position for 2023.

So another from Fiona, potentially destroying a dual mid/edge GUN

Welshy wrote:

So another from Fiona, potentially destroying a dual mid/edge GUN

I think you'll find it's Foina.

Back down to L9. Highest ever was L4 once. This year is my tenth year. I don’t know at what stage I just have to admit I’m not good at this game haha

Welshy wrote:League 2 and League 3 codes have been sent. Please check inboxes and join


Nice Swan.

Cheers Welshy. L3 for me I am happy would love to go a bit better this year though hoping for a top 500 finish.

Milchcow wrote:

There were articles today suggesting Bateman may be eased in off the bench.

I wouldn't trust the job security of Blore (or Seyfarth, or Kepoa, or whoever starts for Tigers in round 1)

Do you think Uto can get 40-45mins? Worth punting on him?

MF wrote:Back down to L9. Highest ever was L4 once. This year is my tenth year. I don’t know at what stage I just have to admit I’m not good at this game haha

we play for fun mate. Definitely be league 1 if we really wanted to

MF wrote:Back down to L9. Highest ever was L4 once. This year is my tenth year. I don’t know at what stage I just have to admit I’m not good at this game haha

Mate, I’ve been playing golf for almost 40 years. Sometimes we are just slow learners, or gluttons for punishment.

Anyone watch the Panthers v St Helens match. I am going to go one of Hoskings or Garner. I am leaning towards Hoskings atm, as I heard Garner looked very average. Any details on substitutions / performances of these two. I know Hoskings did quite well with regard to a Fantasy score.

Only gun edge I’m considering is Fifita. He’s got a bit of value priced in, if you gamble he starts and plays 60+ all season long.

I know everyone else hates him for being lazy, but I find my players playing like shit but still having a 45 base is way better than the rest of my players playing like shit and also scoring shit.

Welshy wrote:

PatRICK Carrigan!

More of a Rick with that wonder tache he was sporting

Didn't see the game. Always fear choosing the wrong one of two high work rate / potentially high minute middle forwards from the same team (Haas, Carrigan) (Tapine, Horsborgh)

Obviously, Carrigan played his guts out, moreso than Haas?

Finger Puppet Mafia wrote:Anyone watch the Panthers v St Helens match. I am going to go one of Hoskings or Garner. I am leaning towards Hoskings atm, as I heard Garner looked very average. Any details on substitutions / performances of these two. I know Hoskings did quite well with regard to a Fantasy score.

Something like team lists would be a huge help to these decisions I’d imagine

Finger Puppet Mafia wrote:Anyone watch the Panthers v St Helens match. I am going to go one of Hoskings or Garner. I am leaning towards Hoskings atm, as I heard Garner looked very average. Any details on substitutions / performances of these two. I know Hoskings did quite well with regard to a Fantasy score.

My conclusion from watching Hosking and Garner in that game is that Sorenson could be starting second row.

Finger Puppet Mafia wrote:

Didn't see the game. Always fear choosing the wrong one of two high work rate / potentially high minute middle forwards from the same team (Haas, Carrigan) (Tapine, Horsborgh)

Obviously, Carrigan played his guts out, moreso than Haas?

ive added carrigan just because hes significantly cheaper than haas

GarethEllisismyDad wrote:holy heck just noticed I joined here one year ago today! was desperately looking around for some info and people to talk nrl fantasy

thank you to all

Much like your father I’m sure you’ll be under appreciated in the rugby league community. Also like him I think you’re a good bloke

Finger Puppet Mafia wrote:

Didn't see the game. Always fear choosing the wrong one of two high work rate / potentially high minute middle forwards from the same team (Haas, Carrigan) (Tapine, Horsborgh)

Obviously, Carrigan played his guts out, moreso than Haas?

For me, with Carrigan it's all about the minutes.

If indeed, he is now "The man" within that donkeys forward rotation and looking at ~65 minutes then his average is around 55-58

Donkeys need him on the field

Welshy wrote:

For me, with Carrigan it's all about the minutes.

If indeed, he is now "The man" within that donkeys forward rotation and looking at ~65 minutes then his average is around 55-58

Donkeys need him on the field

I think Haas is still the man. He played the entire first half in both trials which you can only assume is preparation for playing the entire half during the season. He didn't com on in the second half either week but you'd assume at least another 20 minutes to round out the game. Maybe 25 depending on scoreline

Carrigan played about 30 in the first half, and started the second half when Haas was off the field. Don't think there's any evidence that he plays such big second half minutes if Haas comes back on, but might in close games.

I have them both at the moment but rating Haas significantly ahead of Carrigan.