NRL Fantasy 2022 Part 42 - Tofu Haggis

Loomer wrote:Meaney seasonal average at FB for Dogs hovered between 30-40 and now he's at a much better team. Think it's a risk-free trade with a lot of upside

Khany wrote:Didn't get Tass, didn't notice him having a shocker

wolfking wrote:

Yeah, woke up a bit cold in him, but I'm still interested.  I guess trading him in playing the Panthers is in the back of my mind though.

The Dolphin Conspiracies wrote:Why has everyone suddenly disregarded Meaney?

I cannot see a stronger rationale for a trade-in for ages.

He fills the gap at WFB. Has been putting up keeper scores already on the WNG, is goal kicking and plays for the storm. He will get additional games right across the origin period - perhaps even at HLF. What is not to like?

Bethany_B wrote:

The risk isn't his average (I think he'll go well), the risk is that he doesn't make enough money in 3 games to justify 2 trades, misses 13 and then Papy returns in round 14 (4 weeks post-injury).

I still think he's a good buy but it isn't a risk-free one

Loomer wrote:

Gutherson scored 63 against Panthers last week

my tv broke wrote:I just wouldnt get too excited about a fill in fb this week

wolfking wrote:While yeah it's pouring right now and not going to stop, those issues will be across the board.

my tv broke wrote:

I know that but we are talking about bringing in a guy priced at 35 who will get a few weeks in the position. Its not a trade that you can sit through a few poor scores and wait.

That said, who knows with Papy. Might be out for much longer. At least its not his head this time.

Anyway I don't think its the worst trade. I don't mind it really. I think he's good for 35-40. Expecting more is just hope. He's not going to do Papy things.

wolfking wrote:

There's good arguments for both sides but I don't think anyone trading him in would be expecting him to replicate Pap.  He could be a winner or he could be a more expensive Taffe.

my tv broke wrote:I just wouldnt get too excited about a fill in fb this week

Teeth Eater wrote:

For what it's worth, I'm currently 69th in the NRL FF 2022 FOG league.

ynot wrote:
Warriors: 46.7
Bulldogs: 46.7
Rabbitohs: 47.9
Broncos: 49
Dragons: 50.6

Raiders, Rabbitohs and Broncos are interesting.

my tv broke wrote:If id have made 200k+ on talakai id happily swap him to a proper gun. Plenty of centres goinf round. Dont need one priced over 50 that is actually playing centre.

If you brought him in after the banner then you probably gotta hold and hope now. But that was a terrible case of chasing last weeks score.

Im sure he puts up some more good scores but as with any ctr there will always be 30s in there

WT2K wrote:
A move from Talakai to Tohu could be on the cards next week