Round 10 choices

Starting 17 decisions for this week.

Lineup currently

Smith (c)
Fifita Haas (vc)
Murray Lolo Arrow
Carty ARey
Xerri Nikora
Ponga Teddy CNK

Rein
Mahoney
Taupau
Lawrie

Young
Sivo
Dearden
Lomax


Can change starting HLF or CTR if votes dictate. I feel we should start Xerri over Lomax, both for insurance against a late withdrawal for another WFB, and for Lomax interchange worries.
Happy to go Carty Party/Dearden as poll dictates

We can sub Lawrie out for Dearden/Young/Carty if they go big, so question becomes who we want to have a look at.

Any potential changes to starting team not mentioned here just give suggestions

What a lovely choice between Carty and Dearden haha

Shoutout to the 2 people who voted for === Starting Half === and === Starting CTR === respectively.

How do we use Young to loop? Im probably missing something, but silo locks before young right?

ryno_ wrote:Shoutout to the 2 people who voted for === Starting Half === and === Starting CTR === respectively.

There's some highly intelligent posters here, then there's that guy.

Rippin and Tearin wrote:How do we use Young to loop? Im probably missing something, but silo locks before young right?

You are correct (got confused with my own team looping Martin and Young and just assumed I could loop Young)

The actual decision is play Young or play Lawrie (can't loop them)

Cartwright will be 18th man in the loop.

17th man

Upvote: Lawrie
Downvote: Young

ryno_ wrote:Shoutout to the 2 people who voted for === Starting Half === and === Starting CTR === respectively.

It happens every week.

Its what I'd expect from the forum that is still wondering if Sele is going to get named or not.

Can you see who it was?

I've bumped up Deardon to 18th man as we can loop him.

So decision would be the cut-off for running with him (or not) given we would go with Young otherwise.

Im thinking 45 (upvote)

But more conservative would be 40 (downvote)

Otherwise suggest something else.

Votes can really swing here at times.

6pm yesterday and Dearden was clear winner over Carty, but must have been a big rush overnight for the Party

I'm happy taking 40 if Young is the guy subbing in. I don't think he's the type of player who is going to go ballistic

Milchy wrote:
I'm happy taking 40 if Young is the guy subbing in. I don't think he's the type of player who is going to go ballistic

Sounds fine to me although my brief look at some of his stats suggest he likes a try. I have a hunch he goes BIG in one of his starts.

If we can loop Young, I like him for a bigger score than Dearden

ah, I see, loop Dearden, if he scores 45 leave him there, if not, run Young. I'd be surprised to see Young go under 40 after last week.

The safer decision might be to play Young anyway, and sub Lawrie out if Dearden goes big

Milchy wrote:
The safer decision might be to play Young anyway, and sub Lawrie out if Dearden goes big

I prefer this version.

Milchy wrote:
The safer decision might be to play Young anyway, and sub Lawrie out if Dearden goes big

Lawrie is not in our 17 under the current set up - wasn't that what the earlier vote was for? Lawrie vs Young for 17th man?

Rippin and Tearin wrote:

Lawrie is not in our 17 under the current set up - wasn't that what the earlier vote was for? Lawrie vs Young for 17th man?

Yes, i get confused by answering questions without looking at the team.