Or is he just the most expendable
NRL Fantasy 2024 Part 13 - He looks good, but what do the Reserve Grade stats say
Shady2K- Posts : 5867
Reputation : 3221
Join date : 2020-03-12
What do you do if Sitili plays 80 and scores mid 40s? Maybe run through Burbo for some busts?
Or is he just the most expendable
Or is he just the most expendable
mattnz- Fanatic
- Posts : 18885
Reputation : 6682
Join date : 2018-03-11
Ando wrote:
Mate how many mins do you think for Smithies?
The interesting scenario for me is if they play Horse on the EDG again until Whitehead is back, would be great for Smithies to retain his current big minute role.
mickspicks- Posts : 3298
Reputation : 995
Join date : 2017-04-23
Location : Phin Fully Up 4 Herbie
Shady2K wrote:What do you do if Sitili plays 80 and scores mid 40s? Maybe run through Burbo for some busts?
Or is he just the most expendable
How dare you disrespect Burbo like that
wolfking- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 33040
Reputation : 13281
Join date : 2016-04-26
Age : 39
Location : Brisbane
Aardvark Ratnick wrote:
lol Junior Tatola , sorry mate.
Ah of course. Yeah, trade his ass mate.
rhinoceroo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13802
Reputation : 8938
Join date : 2015-09-30
mattnz wrote:
The interesting scenario for me is if they play Horse on the EDG again until Whitehead is back, would be great for Smithies to retain his current big minute role.
Are you anticipating Young or Hosking getting injured too?
BCT05- Posts : 4560
Reputation : 1880
Join date : 2020-03-19
mattnz wrote:
The interesting scenario for me is if they play Horse on the EDG again until Whitehead is back, would be great for Smithies to retain his current big minute role.
When they have Hosking now? No way
L-Jimmy- Posts : 2630
Reputation : 3272
Join date : 2018-01-16
Age : 41
Location : Dili, East Timor.
mattnz wrote:
The interesting scenario for me is if they play Horse on the EDG again until Whitehead is back, would be great for Smithies to retain his current big minute role.
Red Dwarf, Season 1: Confidence and Paranoia
LISTER: She could've said, "yes." Stranger things have happened!
RIMMER: Only two spring to mind, Lister: the spontaneous combustion of
the Mayor of Warsaw in 1546 and that incident in 12th century Burgundy
when it rained herring.
Aardvark Ratnick- Posts : 2326
Reputation : 1109
Join date : 2015-07-31
wolfking wrote:
Ah of course. Yeah, trade his ass mate.
Yeah but May or Smithies is the ? leaning towards May at this stage.
Ando- Posts : 1451
Reputation : 1673
Join date : 2017-02-16
mattnz wrote:
The interesting scenario for me is if they play Horse on the EDG again until Whitehead is back, would be great for Smithies to retain his current big minute role.
Yeah I think Morg keeps the 13, Hors played EDG last year for a few games but think that was more out of necessity. Shouldn't happen whilst Hosking and Young are available.
mattnz- Fanatic
- Posts : 18885
Reputation : 6682
Join date : 2018-03-11
BCT05 wrote:
When they have Hosking now? No way
Hosking is out when Whitehead is back anyway, might as well give the Horse a good gallop for 80 minutes.
my tv broke- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 27094
Reputation : 19343
Join date : 2016-01-08
mattnz wrote:
Hosking is out when Whitehead is back anyway, might as well give the Horse a good gallop for 80 minutes.
I respect the effort to troll
wolfking- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 33040
Reputation : 13281
Join date : 2016-04-26
Age : 39
Location : Brisbane
mattnz wrote:
Hosking is out when Whitehead is back anyway, might as well give the Horse a good gallop for 80 minutes.
precursor- Posts : 791
Reputation : 630
Join date : 2020-08-09
wolfking wrote:Everyone still rolling Tups out or trading?
I have enough to turn him into May which is tempting but could easily backfire.
Holding, but I also only have 20k so no one I'd like to flick him to anyway. Seyfarth firmly on minutes watch this week though.
rhinoceroo- Fanatic
- Posts : 13802
Reputation : 8938
Join date : 2015-09-30
What are Horsburgh's NSW Cup 2RF stats like?
Boozecluez- Posts : 1563
Reputation : 2113
Join date : 2022-02-04
Age : 39
Location : Sydney
Going to have to sacrifice a fullback to the gods this week
Need to bulk out my mid, took the piss with a few too many fullbacks and last minute squeezed in hynes and it bit me in the ass.
Cheapies going low and the guns not firing and the tunnel looks bleak.
Anyways I enjoy a challenge from 73k overall and for the first time this year actually excited about fantasy again.
While I don't have huge faith in Paps/Rapana I need Pongas cash to combine with Cotric to be able to do anything with it beyond trading sideways
Could run it back with no trades but another red dot or 2 and it would be last drinks without Duncan
So going to take the lazy mid approace and get a couple this week.
2 scorers for the price of one
Out - Ponga+Cotric
In - Smithies+Duncan and 55k bank
Need to bulk out my mid, took the piss with a few too many fullbacks and last minute squeezed in hynes and it bit me in the ass.
Cheapies going low and the guns not firing and the tunnel looks bleak.
Anyways I enjoy a challenge from 73k overall and for the first time this year actually excited about fantasy again.
While I don't have huge faith in Paps/Rapana I need Pongas cash to combine with Cotric to be able to do anything with it beyond trading sideways
Could run it back with no trades but another red dot or 2 and it would be last drinks without Duncan
So going to take the lazy mid approace and get a couple this week.
2 scorers for the price of one
Out - Ponga+Cotric
In - Smithies+Duncan and 55k bank
Boozecluez- Posts : 1563
Reputation : 2113
Join date : 2022-02-04
Age : 39
Location : Sydney
Team this week:
Cook
Cheese Salmon Sitili
Wong Piakura
Cleary Hynes (c)
Strange Burbo
Teddy Papy TTrbo
Smithies Duncan Rapana Chan*
Galvin* Kini Levi Hughes
Cook
Cheese Salmon Sitili
Wong Piakura
Cleary Hynes (c)
Strange Burbo
Teddy Papy TTrbo
Smithies Duncan Rapana Chan*
Galvin* Kini Levi Hughes
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 12867
Reputation : 5616
Join date : 2019-07-24
I was at work but I’ve just got home I am just eating dinner and spat out out in laughter. I rarely get the Souths stuff wrong. The guy with the training update is a guy I’ve spoke with at games several times too he nails it.Brookzy wrote:People seem to think Duncan will be playing on the edge. I’m fairly confident he will be starting lock come game time with Murray on the edge. He will most likely rotate with havili in the lock role. Might get 50 odd minutes.
Training today they were spotted training in the above positions too.
Make of it what you wish
So answer me this if JD said pre season that we could push Murray out to an edge if needed at times and play Tallis through the middle why are we shocked about it?….. it’s JD too we are talking about often his team selections make no sense. Duncan has never played edge before did not spend a minute there in pre season why will that change now? Murray edge has been floated around too as a way to ease his workload just a bit too given he’s so bashed up already his shoulders are fucked from being battered in the middle and he’s only 25 years old. Murray is also bloody great on the edge and Tallis is a gun.
Secondly coaches what they name is not always how they run out sometimes they play mind games. Souths often last year didn’t run out how they were named on the Tuesday.
Thirdly if Murray was training right edge the whole session today 2 days out from the game what does that tell you and the fact Duncan and Havili were in the middle alternating?
MattNZ is right too on what he said at 45-50mins at lock Duncan is a wait a week and watch thing. I expect Murray and Keaon to play 80mins and there is 4 middles on the bench. I can’t see Duncan getting 55-60mins intially no way it’s a long year too.
Anyway people don’t fume when Duncan is not playing big mins on the edge come Thursday and don’t be angry if Havili comes on for him around 24mins into the game.
Aside from this I’m seeing a lot of panic. People overreacting and rage trading and forgetting it’s a marathon and not a sprint. You know what I think I might just hold both trades this week.
Milchcow- Moderator
- Posts : 24542
Reputation : 16970
Join date : 2015-07-31
rhinoceroo wrote:What are Horsburgh's NSW Cup 2RF stats like?
he once scored over 100 fantasy points in a trial game
At least, we think it was him - he was listed as "Canberra no 10" or something similar on the team sheet
Rabbits21- Fanatic
- Posts : 12867
Reputation : 5616
Join date : 2019-07-24
Oh and aside for that I do not see more than 45mins for Tatola at most probs more low 40’s mins if I had him I think I would trade him as we have a 4 forward bench with all middles.
wolfking- Fanatics Immortal
- Posts : 33040
Reputation : 13281
Join date : 2016-04-26
Age : 39
Location : Brisbane
Rabbits21 wrote:
I was at work but I’ve just got home I am just eating dinner and spat out out in laughter. I rarely get the Souths stuff wrong. The guy with the training update is a guy I’ve spoke with at games several times too he nails it.
So answer me this if JD said pre season that we could push Murray out to an edge if needed at times and play Tallis through the middle why are we shocked about it?….. it’s JD too we are talking about often his team selections make no sense. Duncan has never played edge before did not spend a minute there in pre season why will that change now? Murray edge has been floated around too as a way to ease his workload just a bit too given he’s so bashed up already his shoulders are fucked from being battered in the middle and he’s only 25 years old. Murray is also bloody great on the edge and Tallis is a gun.
Secondly coaches what they name is not always how they run out sometimes they play mind games. Souths often last year didn’t run out how they were named on the Tuesday.
Thirdly if Murray was training right edge the whole session today 2 days out from the game what does that tell you and the fact Duncan and Havili were in the middle alternating?
MattNZ is right too on what he said at 45-50mins at lock Duncan is a wait a week and watch thing. I expect Murray and Keaon to play 80mins and there is 4 middles on the bench. I can’t see Duncan getting 55-60mins intially no way it’s a long year too.
Anyway people don’t fume when Duncan is not playing big mins on the edge come Thursday and don’t be angry if Havili comes on for him around 24mins into the game.
Aside from this I’m seeing a lot of panic. People overreacting and rage trading and forgetting it’s a marathon and not a sprint. You know what I think I might just hold both trades this week.
Didn't Brookzy who you quoted say the same thing you just did?
Also, I loled at the bolded part.