NRL Fantasy 2023 Part 18 - Catchy Thread Title

Would you get Turbo or Walsh next week?

Assuming Turbo 660k~ and Walsh 580k~

Shady2K wrote:Would you get Turbo or Walsh next week?

Assuming Turbo 660k~ and Walsh 580k~

If you're buying one or the other Turbo 100 times out of 100.

I already own Walsh so I would be buying Turbo (since Boyd did well I may go E Butch and Trindall to Turbo and Soni Luke next week)

Walsh trade locked in next week simply for shitposting purposes. (Not the only factor, but the deciding one.)

Aardvark wrote:10/561(c) no idea what that means

It means you're doing a lot better than my 569/13c

6/8 on ATS try scorers, fox and ronaldo to complete the haul!

If I can figure out a good combo of outs + 207k that gets Walsh and Bird in my team, that will be locked in, first thought is Loeiro + Sutton if he has a repeat of last week, but I think that still falls short.

rhinoceroo wrote:Walsh trade locked in next week simply for shitposting purposes. (Not the only factor, but the deciding one.)

this is the way

Contrastinghobby wrote:@mattnz
Using the same example of Walsh, what makes his stats any different to Kiraz?
Kiraz has doubled his career average tackle breaks and tripled his offloads this year along with 2 tries
If we are talking his base stats it’s less than 20pts based on a handful of tackles and 100+ run metres

Point is you are buying him for attacking stats, the only difference is you don’t own Walsh

You can buy him too if you want

#nonwalshowner

This is the biggest load of shit you have posted here. Check out my team tracker if you want the truth on Kiraz and his base stats.

The guy is taking 20+ hit ups a game like Edwards does, when he gets a couple of tries he scores 90, not 52.

In round 1, when his team got thumped and he went off for an HIA, he still scored 48, with 0 attacking chances. Without the HIA he beats the Walsh score this week.

Has a career average of 2.5 offloads and has increased his work rate coming out of his own end to what his coach was getting out of Panthers backs like Edwards, Too and May.

Aardvark wrote:10/561(c) no idea what that means

That seems really good

Bethany_B wrote:

If you're buying one or the other Turbo 100 times out of 100.

I already own Walsh so I would be buying Turbo (since Boyd did well I may go E Butch and Trindall to Turbo and Soni Luke next week)

Just tossing up some options but yeah Turbo in isolation looks much better

Could also go for a gun CTR like Bird, or a gun HLF like ARey/SJ. Based on what I've seen SJ looks great value if he can stay fit

Was at a wedding party all night. Glad Walsh fired for those who brought him in, and happy Carrigan got a very solid score for those who had him.

Other than those of us who played (or had to play) Warbrick, it seems like a great night of Fantasy for the forum!

Shady2K wrote:Would you get Turbo or Walsh next week?

Assuming Turbo 660k~ and Walsh 580k~

For me personally, although I am a Turbo owner and not a Walsh owner, I would go Turbo. Watching Manly, he is constantly involved. I feel like despite Walshe's brilliance, Turbo will be a more consistent scorer since he is always involved.

Shady2K wrote:

Just tossing up some options but yeah Turbo in isolation looks much better

Could also go for a gun CTR like Bird, or a gun HLF like ARey/SJ. Based on what I've seen SJ looks great value if he can stay fit

Yeah that's fair enough, SJ could be a good shout and Bird seems like he'll be the no. 1 CTR unless he gets moved out of the forward pack.

I started with both Bird and Walsh so I don't need to spend trades buying them, so Turbo is top of my list at the moment (if Boyd had had another stinker I'd be going a gun HOK first but he's holding the fort nicely)

Shady2K wrote:Would you get Turbo or Walsh next week?

Assuming Turbo 660k~ and Walsh 580k~

Turbo 100%. Has had a whole season playing like he did this week and puts up a 75 when he scores a couple of tries.

Snatchpato wrote:Was at a wedding party all night. Glad Walsh fired for those who brought him in, and happy Carrigan got a very solid score for those who had him.

Other than those of us who played (or had to play) Warbrick, it seems like a great night of Fantasy for the forum!

Very relieved with the Carrigan score, should be back to normal next week.

Shady2K wrote:Would you get Turbo or Walsh next week?

Assuming Turbo 660k~ and Walsh 580k~

despite being walshes biggest cheerleader prolly turbo,

but if you need the money elsewhere walsh is a decent understudy

and I have guaranteed a ton, in the next 5 fixtures, one down

mattnz wrote:

This is the biggest load of shit you have posted here. Check out my team tracker if you want the truth on Kiraz and his base stats.

The guy is taking 20+ hit ups a game like Edwards does, when he gets a couple of tries he scores 90, not 52.

In round 1, when his team got thumped and he went off for an HIA, he still scored 48, with 0 attacking chances. Without the HIA he beats the Walsh score this week.

Has a career average of 2.5 offloads and has increased his work rate coming out of his own end to what his coach was getting out of Panthers backs like Edwards, Too and May.

Webster was the attack coach at the Panthers, not Ciraldo. You should be buying Marcello Montoya.

608/13c

Trindall, Doueihi, Alamoti, Preston to go

Seems pretty poor really

Waish was sniffing around the first half but not getting the ball, tries and try assists will become his base.

rhinoceroo wrote:

Webster was the attack coach at the Panthers, not Ciraldo. You should be buying Marcello Montoya.

He was at the only club where the expectation of every outside back was that they run the ball back constantly and take a hit up every set, which is what Kiraz is now doing.

It seems that Walters either doesn't require that of his backs, or Walsh isn't capable of it.