How to Vote:
Basically tell me what trades you would make this week for the team.
1. Tell me how many trades yuou would make (0, 1 or 2)
2. If you picked 0 trades stop there.
3. If you picked 1 trade tell me who to drop and who you'd add
4. If you picked 2 trades pick the two you would drop and two you would add.
Final Note: Please make sure your trades make sense. I.e. don't pick one trade, Drop Sivo and Add Bateman (we don't have the cash for that)
Basically there are too many combinations to list them all individually and from this I should get a good idea of where the communities head is at. If it's not clear I'll run a quickfire poll with 2-3 select options on Thursday.
Situation we have is 55k cash ITB and a team as follows:
Macca
Fifita, Tolman
Murray, Lane, Arrow
Morgan, Keighran
Nikora, Capewell
Sivo, Edwards, CNK
Taupau, Mahoney, Holland, Garner
Burr, Brown, Garrick, Ravalawa
No-one really disappointed barring:
- Sivo and Garrick.
If we want anyone above 267k we listed potential cut targets as:
- Holland
- Lane
- Edwards
- Arrow
- Taupau
The majority of trade ins suggested have been
- Sele
- Host
- Bird
- Lawrie
- Burns
- Bateman
When you vote feel free to put your logic in here. Might sway more people to your way of thinking.
Personally a few of my favourite ideas are:
2 trades:
@rhinoceroo
Holland -> Burns
and
Garrick -> Lawrie
*logic being that Lawrie will generate more cash than Garrick and be playable in 17. Capewell moves to centre meaning Burns can be a safer scorer at wing than Sivo/Rava. I also think Holland is overrated on here. A centre on a wooden spoon team is scoring under 30 more often than not, goalkicks or not.
@Shanbon
Tapau -> Bateman
and
Holland -> Host (Lawrie if you like him more)
Will score at least the same amount but while the ceiling isn’t as high the floor is a lot higher. Also saves a heap of cash (444k) for the following week if a few cows are still underperforming.
@Rippin and Tearin
Holland -> Host/Lawrie
Edwards -> Gillet
Would play Ravalawa in the empty WFB spot. That would leave 190k ITB. Then next week I would then move Lane to Bateman (should be ~$40k) and use the remaining $ to grab the best cow we've missed next week, turning Garrick/Sivo/Burr into someone like Burns who could din turn bump out Sivo from the WFBs