Dally M Awards
Moose- Posts : 2215
Reputation : 1289
Join date : 2017-05-19
- Post n°21
Re: Dally M Awards
Didn't watch the awards. Did Cam Smith win referee of the year?
ryno_- NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2018
Posts : 2230
Reputation : 490
Join date : 2015-09-27
Age : 34
- Post n°22
Re: Dally M Awards
Dip wrote:
I read that as saying "The judges don't have to actually watch them play, we give them their SuperCoach scores and ask them to vote based on that."
Who are the judges? If (say) Joey is a judge, im sure he wouldnt give extra points to players he mentors. What would he have to benefit from his mentoree winning a DallyM half of the year award.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°23
Re: Dally M Awards
ryno_ wrote:
Who are the judges? If (say) Joey is a judge, im sure he wouldnt give extra points to players he mentors. What would he have to benefit from his mentoree winning a DallyM half of the year award.
from the same article:
Greg Alexander
Braith Anasta
Richie Barnett
Gary Belcher
Monty Betham
Darryl Brohman
Danny Buderus
Brett Finch
Brad Fittler
Joe Galuvao
Mark Gasnier
Ryan Girdler
Daryl Halligan
Andrew Johns
Dallas Johnson
Brett Kimmorley
Darren Lockyer
Steve Menzies
Steve Roach
Andrew Ryan
Jimmy Smith
Peter Sterling
Alan Tongue
Kevin Walters
might as well just post the link for anyone who wants to take a look: http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/dally-m-medal-and-awards-voting-system-explained/news-story/efb0d6d0c5fef01577a498e7ecacfaf0
code delta- Posts : 3245
Reputation : 1715
Join date : 2016-05-05
- Post n°24
Re: Dally M Awards
surmo13 wrote:
from the same article:
Greg Alexander
Braith Anasta
Richie Barnett
Gary Belcher
Monty Betham
Darryl Brohman
Danny Buderus
Brett Finch
Brad Fittler
Joe Galuvao
Mark Gasnier
Ryan Girdler
Daryl Halligan
Andrew Johns
Dallas Johnson
Brett Kimmorley
Darren Lockyer
Steve Menzies
Steve Roach
Andrew Ryan
Jimmy Smith
Peter Sterling
Alan Tongue
Kevin Walters
might as well just post the link for anyone who wants to take a look: http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/dally-m-medal-and-awards-voting-system-explained/news-story/efb0d6d0c5fef01577a498e7ecacfaf0
Surely it would be quicker and easier to get the right results if all the above were replaced as judges by,
Dip
Ice
OSM
surmo
ryno
Pieman.
A fish has the casting vote.
ryno_- NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2018
Posts : 2230
Reputation : 490
Join date : 2015-09-27
Age : 34
- Post n°25
Re: Dally M Awards
code delta wrote:
Surely it would be quicker and easier to get the right results if all the above were replaced as judges by,
Dip
Ice
OSM
surmo
ryno
Pieman.
A fish has the casting vote.
:lol:
Only if I don't have to watch any Newcastle games.
Oz Sport Mad- Posts : 1896
Reputation : 733
Join date : 2015-09-28
- Post n°26
Re: Dally M Awards
code delta wrote:
Surely it would be quicker and easier to get the right results if all the above were replaced as judges by,
Dip
Ice
OSM
surmo
ryno
Pieman.
A fish has the casting vote.
Look obviously it would be fucking painful having to deal with Ice and Pieman's ridiculous suggestions (Hayne/Mannah votes would need to be culled significantly).
But I think between the rest of the blokes selected, we'd get the right result.....and Milf or the FAC would fight it out for Dally M.
ryno_- NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2018
Posts : 2230
Reputation : 490
Join date : 2015-09-27
Age : 34
- Post n°27
Re: Dally M Awards
Oz Sport Mad wrote:
Look obviously it would be fucking painful having to deal with Ice and Pieman's ridiculous suggestions (Hayne/Mannah votes would need to be culled significantly).
But I think between the rest of the blokes selected, we'd get the right result.....and Milf or the FAC would fight it out for Dally M.
Why don't we just create an award for the fastest roll ball? That way Mannah gets a nod and everyone's happy.
Pieman- Posts : 3553
Reputation : 386
Join date : 2015-10-26
- Post n°28
Re: Dally M Awards
Incidental contact with the head hey Ozzy, no suspension there - give him 3 points for a standard textbook tackle
Oz Sport Mad- Posts : 1896
Reputation : 733
Join date : 2015-09-28
- Post n°29
Re: Dally M Awards
ryno_ wrote:
Why don't we just create an award for the fastest roll ball? That way Mannah gets a nod and everyone's happy.
In fairness to Ice, ever since this claim has been made about Mannah I've made a real concerted effort to watch Big Timmy and whether he has this ability for landing on his front and thus getting a quick play the ball.
My conclusion.......he's no fucking better or worse than about 50 other props in the comp.
Oz Sport Mad- Posts : 1896
Reputation : 733
Join date : 2015-09-28
- Post n°30
Re: Dally M Awards
Pieman wrote:Incidental contact with the head hey Ozzy, no suspension there - give him 3 points for a standard textbook tackle
Exactly right should be on the judiciary too.
I wouldn't expect a deadset simpleton like yourself to understand common Rugby League sense though.....
Pieman- Posts : 3553
Reputation : 386
Join date : 2015-10-26
- Post n°31
Re: Dally M Awards
Yes, the common sense that its play on when poor technique means a shoulder hits someone in the head. Nothin to see here
Dip- Posts : 1597
Reputation : 283
Join date : 2015-09-30
- Post n°32
Re: Dally M Awards
Oz Sport Mad wrote:
In fairness to Ice, ever since this claim has been made about Mannah I've made a real concerted effort to watch Big Timmy and whether he has this ability for landing on his front and thus getting a quick play the ball.
My conclusion.......he's no fucking better or worse than about 50 other props in the comp.
Parra had the fastest play the balls in the competition this year, mainly because every play the ball is an Andrew Fifita like touch footy roll ball. Mitchell Moses is the worst. Every single time he plays the ball he lands on his face. I don't know how that happens if you're on your feet and heeling it back.
ryno_- NRL FF Survivor Champion : 2018
Posts : 2230
Reputation : 490
Join date : 2015-09-27
Age : 34
- Post n°33
Re: Dally M Awards
Dip wrote:
Parra had the fastest play the balls in the competition this year, mainly because every play the ball is an Andrew Fifita like touch footy roll ball. Mitchell Moses is the worst. Every single time he plays the ball he lands on his face. I don't know how that happens if you're on your feet and heeling it back.
Anybody younger then 27, regardless of talent, rolls the ball like that. Pet peeve. Roll it with your heel you peanut.
Pieman- Posts : 3553
Reputation : 386
Join date : 2015-10-26
- Post n°34
Re: Dally M Awards
Why should they? They dont get penalised for not doing it correctly.
Until the refs crack down on it, nothing will change. They prefer having a fast paced game over stopping and enforcing the rules.
It's prob time they do away with the rule and just say put it on the ground and roll it because thats what happens now anyway.
Obv I would prefer if they just started policing the rule
Until the refs crack down on it, nothing will change. They prefer having a fast paced game over stopping and enforcing the rules.
It's prob time they do away with the rule and just say put it on the ground and roll it because thats what happens now anyway.
Obv I would prefer if they just started policing the rule
Ice- Posts : 1538
Reputation : 121
Join date : 2015-10-22
- Post n°35
Re: Dally M Awards
Oz Sport Mad wrote:
Look obviously it would be fucking painful having to deal with Ice and Pieman's ridiculous suggestions (Hayne/Mannah votes would need to be culled significantly).
But I think between the rest of the blokes selected, we'd get the right result.....and Milf or the FAC would fight it out for Dally M.
Haha, that's a little harsh. I can be impartial, just as much, possibly more so than Queenslanders/Broncos fans.
Last edited by Ice on Fri Sep 29, 2017 10:03 pm; edited 1 time in total
Ice- Posts : 1538
Reputation : 121
Join date : 2015-10-22
- Post n°36
Re: Dally M Awards
Oz Sport Mad wrote:
In fairness to Ice, ever since this claim has been made about Mannah I've made a real concerted effort to watch Big Timmy and whether he has this ability for landing on his front and thus getting a quick play the ball.
My conclusion.......he's no fucking better or worse than about 50 other props in the comp.
Honestly, I think he has slowed down a little, but someone has to be the quickest and when I was spruiking it two or three years ago, it was him. I haven't talked him up for ages,but he gets the job done for the Eels for the most part. A cursory glance out our performance when he is on compared to when he is off shows his value. But it's unlikely he would have garnered many points from me this year. Not to say he was bad, just not in our top three. But sure,you guys hang on to that.
Ice- Posts : 1538
Reputation : 121
Join date : 2015-10-22
- Post n°37
Re: Dally M Awards
Dip wrote:
Parra had the fastest play the balls in the competition this year, mainly because every play the ball is an Andrew Fifita like touch footy roll ball. Mitchell Moses is the worst. Every single time he plays the ball he lands on his face. I don't know how that happens if you're on your feet and heeling it back.
True, imagine how far we'd be ahead if Mannah was at his peak.
Guest- Guest
- Post n°38
Re: Dally M Awards
code delta wrote:
Surely it would be quicker and easier to get the right results if all the above were replaced as judges by,
Dip
Ice
OSM
surmo
ryno
Pieman.
A fish has the casting vote.
Is that... is that me?
Pieman- Posts : 3553
Reputation : 386
Join date : 2015-10-26
- Post n°39
Re: Dally M Awards
Ice wrote:
Haha, that's a little harsh. I can be impartial, just as much, possibly more so than Queenslanders/Broncos fans.
Ice, do you think Bronco fans are aware of their own inferiority complex? Or thats just how they are brought up so it is what it is?
Ice- Posts : 1538
Reputation : 121
Join date : 2015-10-22
- Post n°40
Re: Dally M Awards
Pieman wrote:
Ice, do you think Bronco fans are aware of their own inferiority complex? Or thats just how they are brought up so it is what it is?
I think they learn it from birth, it's a strange phenomenon. Bit i don't like to put them all in the same box