Feeney or Gutherson

Since I can do it here  I think it is pretty relevant though, they both look like they can score enough to be in my 17 at wfb and I doubt I'm the only one thinking it.

Have them both and play one in your 17 based on fixtures

^ yeah, I would play Feeney purely because he will be playing FB and Wingers generally score bad.

Milchcow wrote:
Have them both and play one in your 17 based on fixtures

I know plenty of gun coaches including you do this but every time I do it I end up selecting the dud.

Krump wrote:
I know plenty of gun coaches including you do this but every time I do it I end up selecting the dud.

Wait are you saying you wont have Gutherson or Feeney? I think you should have both in your team (As did Milch) but you should play Feeney. If you don't have them who are your other NPR's?

Random wrote:

Wait are you saying you wont have Gutherson or Feeney? I think you should have both in your team (As did Milch) but you should play Feeney. If you don't have them who are your other NPR's?

I have both. It was who should I have in my 17(first poll I'm still learning).
I'm leaning to Feeney as well but Gutherson is a proven scorer. I just saw a team in the rate my my team thread with Feeney at wfb and Gutherson at centre and doesn't that open some possibilities

How about you wait until round 1 team lists come out.

B/L wrote:How about you wait until round 1 team lists come out.

Too far away

B/L wrote:How about you wait until round 1 team lists come out.

Or I could stimulate some dicussion about 2 relatively similar players now and then we've all got something to argue about. or I could have the wait until rd 1 attitude like you... Hang on, why are you hanging around here before rd 1?

B/L wrote:How about you wait until round 1 team lists come out.

OK. Feeney is fullback and Gutherson is on the wing.

Now what?

I read somewhere that Taka played on Semi's side last season and he was a big reason Semi scored a lot of tries. It also said Gutherson would play outside Taka this season with Jennings on Semi's side.

I am not saying Gutherson will be the new Semi but if Taka was giving Semi a lot of good ball then Gutherson would have the potential to score well maybe?

Does that make any sense?

Im not sold on Feeney, even if he is even named at fullback round 1.

A few early losses and poor performances and he will be out the back door.

I'm a fuckhead.